Your Caribbean Online: HomeNewsSportsVibesMembersLinksMusicClassifiedsAbout Us
Search For Tips

 
invite a friend to this pageRead comments and post your own

Redemption Song Sculpture

A 3,320-pound bronze sculpture called Redemption Song unveiled on July 31 in Kingston, Jamaica has become the latest controversy on the island. The statue portrays two former slaves, a male and a female standing in a pool of water with their eyes looking towards the sky. Why the controversy? Both statues are naked as the day they were born and the man who stands about 11 feet tall has a penis that...well...stands tall on its own. Some criticize what they observe as inappropriate European features chiseled in the woman's face.

Emblazoned on the base of the statue are the words of Marcus Garvey put to music by Bob Marley in the song that gave the statue its name "none but ourselves can free our mind." Those who support the statue suggest the controversy over its nakedness is evidence that Jamaicans may not yet be free from the mental slavery that Garvey and Marley discussed. Many of Europe's most famous sculptures are in the nude and are considered works of art.

Does size matter? It appears that the focal point over the debate has become the man's penis, or to be more specific the size of it. Laura Facey-Cooper, the Jamaican sculptor who created the statue says "I did not particularly enlarge that part of the male body to the exclusion of anything else. He has very strong muscles in his torso and buttocks. Both the male and female are very well-endowed in every possible way."

Several Jamaicans are calling for the Patterson administration to remove the statue from the newly named Emancipation Park in which it stands. This would not be the first time a statue has been recalled in Jamaica. During the 1980's sculptor Christopher Gonzales was commissioned to create a statue to honor the late Jamaican reggae superstar Bob Marley. After it's completion the government, then led by Edward Seaga decided that it was not what they were looking for and commissioned Alvin Mariott to erect another which now stands in front of Jamaica's National Stadium. Gonzales's statue spent much of the 20 years since in the National Gallery before its recent placement at the Island Village in Ocho Rios.

At a recent concert in the Emancipation Park given in honor Jamaica's beloved Miss Lou (Louise Bennett-Coverly) popular Deejay Tony Rebel pleaded to Jamaica's Prime Minister P.J. Patterson "Mister prime minister, take down the naked people and put up a statue of Miss Lou instead." Many of the over 10,000 in attendance cheered in support. In a release by the sculptor, Laura Facey Cooper upon the release of the statue she stated "It is my hope that our Jamaican people will be moved by Redemption Song." She appears to have gotten her wish...what do you think?

invite a friend to this page
Read comments and post your own
Release from the Sculptor


Redemption Song Sculpture Forum

Name
Email
From
Opinion
undecided
Comments
 
 
 

 Name: Tafa

Comments:
This is a wonderful work of art, there is absolutely nothing wrong with our nakedness and we need to come to grips with it.

8/10/03 3:30:21 PM
 Name: Chineyl

Comments:
"None but ourselves can free our mind." This Sculpture shows (among other things) free mind and speech. Taking it down would only depict that we have not yet moved forward. "Now is the time to lift every voice" This is one way to be heard.......

08/10/2003 11:21:30 PM
 Name: DA

Comments:
Mind, Body & Soul ~ All so beautiful in truth & freedom. Beautiful statues. I hope it is allowed to stand and stay.

08/10/2003 11:56:06 PM
 Name: DA

Comments:
Mind, Body & Soul ~ All so beautiful in truth & freedom. Beautiful statues. I hope it is allowed to stand and stay.

08/10/2003 11:56:06 PM
 Name: sharon

Comments:
people are just too uptight about nudity

08/12/2003 8:35:33 AM
 Name: maureen

Comments:
The west has taught us to be ashamed of our african bodies and to cover up with materials they sell us at exorbitant prices and sadly enough we are agreeing with them by creating controversy over something this beautiful.

08/12/2003 4:57:45 PM
 Name: Nya

Comments:
Will some in the carribean ever abandon archaic social concepts? Lovely piece of artwork.Time to move forward

08/13/2003 7:48:46 AM
 Name: pan2pan

Comments:
we've been taught well, be ashamed of the african body it's suppposedly ugly and by all means let's pass this on to our children-the very irony of the word beneath this statue???

08/13/2003 12:13:47 PM
 Name: Phil Doyle

Comments:
Its a great piece of work. It screams of rebirth and the innocense of a black Adam and Eve. Its beautiful in a world with far more important things to get upset, it is those that are upset by other peoples nakedness that have a problem. Get over it!

08/14/2003 12:05:55 PM
 Name: Marvin

Comments:
The outcry is misguided. The real problem in Jamaica is the social deterioration brought on by unemployment, violence and drugs. The statues' nakedness do not depict anything one cannot find in a child's biology book so it is entirely acceptable.

08/14/2003 1:40:22 PM
 Name: rebekah

Comments:
there is nothing emancipating about it. just two naked people staring listlessly in the sky, waiting for salvation instead of redemption it seems.

08/15/2003 2:14:41 AM
 Name: tu-tu

Comments:
i dont have a problem with the nudity aspect of the statue. I just dont think that it has anything to do with the theme.

08/15/2003 2:18:16 AM
 Name: Niyi

Comments:
I love it / We as a people have our own identity / and we know ourselves / we need not listen to european-mind washed persons about how to express ourselves

08/15/2003 1:07:22 PM
 Name: Eulette

Comments:
I think this statute represents freedom from being slaves, the feeling of being born again, starting a new life as real people and not as caged animals. I see the removal of the clothes as a symbol of that freedom and should be viewed in that context. Besides, there is nothing shameful about the naked body.

08/17/2003 3:57:25 AM
 Name: Chris Staton

Comments:
This is in it's natural form .. with everythihng else that is in the media .. whoat is wrong with a symbol of HISTORY .. as long as the elders .. the older ones explain what is represents to the younger generation .. I can see this only making our black society more stronger and more aware of our Heritage.

08/17/2003 2:02:59 PM
 Name:

Comments:
The statue should be looked at for what it symbolizes. It is a wonderful work of art and should be allowed to remain where it stands.

08/18/2003 2:57:05 PM
 Name: taba

Comments:
Its a beautiful piece. Strong and alive. It shows we are on our way to where we want to be, and we're getting there with pride.

08/18/2003 5:38:45 PM
 Name: seajay

Comments:
If one wants to express her visions on freedom with the world than why cant we , the world appreciate it an look beyond just two naked people and see what that person was trying to emphasis!

08/20/2003 10:58:54 PM
 Name: Ade

Comments:
The artist's interpretation of the Redemption Song is ingenious and, in fact, the nude aspect of her work of art should not be shocking as it is not totally farfetched to see freedom in nudity. I am flying home just to see it...and I am taking lots of friends too! Yeah, Laura, you have certainly added to our Emancipation celebration and TOURISM!!!

08/21/2003 1:59:34 PM
 Name:

Comments:
"none but ourselves can free our minds"..nudity is as real as it gets and the sooner our people are able to let go of the old fashion belief that nudity is nasty the sooner we can all move forward. After all other than the Nuns (and these days u never know), who does not get naked with another person? Our population would not be growing otherwise. this is a wonderful thing. Let it shine

08/24/2003 10:09:37 AM
 Name: Edwin Wilson

Comments:
WE SHOULD'NT BE ASHAME OF OUR NATURAL aFRICAN bEAUTY

08/24/2003 12:31:01 PM
 Name: AnoneMus

Comments:
Ya man, I agree with the comment above we should not be afraid of our natural African Booty...ah...Beauty ;-)

08/25/2003 1:26:58 AM
 Name: noja

Comments:
Neither for it nor against but I think the theme has been lost. It's the Artist's personal expression only; nutten emancipating and I love my nudity.

08/27/2003 9:22:49 PM
 Name: Sexytee

Comments:
There is nothing wrong with nude statues but this particular statue is not representative of emancipation. It is my opinion that the artist should have put alot more thought about the idea of emancipation then sculpt accordingly.

08/29/2003 10:52:20 AM
 Name: BB

Comments:
Theres nothing wrong with the statue. Most of the fuss is because the man has a 'big' penis.

09/01/2003 7:41:05 AM
 Name: Vale Harcourt

Comments:
Sublime and unforgettable

09/01/2003 7:43:18 AM
 Name:

Comments:

09/01/2003 11:52:39 AM
 Name: Ian

Comments:
It's not about the nudity, people! It's about the size of the penis. You cannot blame the sculptor if she builds from experience...

09/01/2003 11:56:16 AM
 Name: Juvenile

Comments:
WHAT IN GOD'S NAME IS THAT THING!!!!!!!

09/01/2003 5:19:21 PM
 Name:

Comments:
If I had not done Art Appreciation, I would probably be reluctant to having a statue as such for public display. In understanding the people's point of view, their education must be taken into consideration. What will happen if they do not consider this a work of art is destruction of the property. Either therefore, the people will have to be educated in the arts or the statue has to be relocated.

09/02/2003 10:10:03 AM
 Name: Allie-I

Comments:
It is not shameful to be nude, but it is a shame to be ashamed of nudity. The human body is Jah creation, and nudity is a natural state. The nudity of this statue conveys the vulnerability and helplessness of Africans in slavery and since slavery. We "free" people need to emancipate our minds and embrace the beauty of the human body. The greatest riches of Africa are those very bodies, which were stolen and sold into slavery. And frankly, his penis is not that "big". Her breasts are quite full, too - but that doesn't seem to be a controversy... It's ok to see the female body naked, but not the male...?

09/04/2003 9:28:02 AM
 Name: Robert

Comments:
Nice!

09/04/2003 5:22:59 PM
 Name: Demitrius

Comments:
Nice penis...

09/05/2003 10:17:38 AM
 Name: Lexley Earle

Comments:
Full time we go beyond petty morallities and appreciate work of arts. We tends to be afraid of our naturalities, remember we were even strip of our clothing and wip in slavery days........Lets all be proud of our masculinity,and femininity.

09/05/2003 2:27:06 PM
 Name: Mathurin Jerome

Comments:
If we accept that there were slaves, black african slaves that is, and if we are going to portray them, then we have to portray them the way they were.

09/05/2003 8:37:02 PM
 Name: Vinetta Laing

Comments:
Oh, what "aesthetic beauty"! This reminds me of the story about Adam and Eve in the Garden of Eden. Let us not equate aesthetic beauty with ignorance. Occasionally we are trapped by our own ignorance, not understanding the true definition of a word or topic. Art is from the Heart and Laura has demonstrated it in her works. In addition, by definition, Art is "the ability of man (woman) to arrange or to adapt things or conditions to his (her) own uses (and for us to understand). The creation of works that are, in form, content, and execution, Esthetically pleasing and meaningful, as in music, painting, literature, architecture, SCULPTURE, etc." Great job Laura. Keep up the good labor. A W S O M E!

09/07/2003 9:24:15 PM
 Name: Rob Manfredi

Comments:

09/10/2003 11:14:34 AM
 Name: Jana Frost

Comments:
I am a sculptor and find the statue to be exactly as the artist intended-food for the mind..the fact they are naked only adds to the beauty of it. A marvelous job capturing muscle tone and correct human form..art is and will forever be about opinion...and my opinion is that is speaks to freedom-as it should given the topic.

09/10/2003 11:37:22 AM
 Name: Dianne

Comments:
they're rising from the depths and looking upwards...i think the nakedness represents newness. and i think the bodies depicted are both equally well-endowed and in proportion... but more importantly, they are both STRONG and beautiful.

09/10/2003 11:40:51 AM
 Name: D. Dixon

Comments:
The statue is very much a fine piece of art work but it does not capture the whole essence of the term "emancipation".

09/10/2003 12:15:43 PM
 Name: dixie

Comments:
the statue is most definetly a fine work of art, however we need a statue that will represent and capture the true essence of emancipation. we need a statue that will dictate, to foreigners as well as locals, when they pass the park, that yes this is emancipation park.

09/10/2003 12:29:05 PM
 Name: Mariana

Comments:
it's a beautiful sculpture!!

09/10/2003 1:36:40 PM
 Name:

Comments:

09/10/2003 1:36:41 PM
 Name:

Comments:
if your offended by the penis you must be packing a vienna sausage

09/10/2003 1:56:20 PM
 Name: Dingus

Comments:
I can barely see anything wrong with the statue. Prudery should be exposed in all cases. The long and the short of it is: It's a statue; it's art; artists go to great lengths to express themselves, and we should let them.

09/10/2003 2:32:55 PM
 Name:

Comments:

09/10/2003 2:48:39 PM
 Name: Professor L.

Comments:
Figures of massive dignity, two classical gods. Nobody told me of the brilliant way the base makes it seem as if they're surging upward. Such a complex art work and all the average person can find in it is the size of his penis? Depressing.

09/10/2003 2:49:27 PM
 Name: Professor L.

Comments:
Figures of massive dignity, two classical gods. Nobody told me of the brilliant way the base makes it seem as if they're surging upward. Such a complex art work and all the average person can find in it is the size of his penis? Depressing.

09/10/2003 2:51:11 PM
 Name: Professor L.

Comments:
Figures of massive dignity, two classical gods. Nobody told me of the brilliant way the base makes it seem as if they're surging upward. Such a complex art work and all the average person can find in it is the size of his penis? Depressing.

09/10/2003 2:51:15 PM
 Name: Rose

Comments:
I am not of African decent, I do not live in Jamaica but in my opinion it is a beautiful tribute to freedom! The 2 are free of all that had chained them. Beautiful!!

09/10/2003 3:41:42 PM
 Name: Russell

Comments:
It must be cold, because as a Jamaican man I know the real thing to be a bit larger. Maybe the artist did not want to scare the tourists.

09/10/2003 3:53:43 PM
 Name:

Comments:

09/10/2003 3:56:20 PM
 Name: geoff

Comments:
I like it. I'm not sure it says "redemtion" (at least from slavery), but its moving. If you dont like it, you got eyelids.

09/10/2003 4:40:10 PM
 Name: stan

Comments:
Europeans have done nudes for centuries. People are just mad that he is endowed the way he is.

09/10/2003 5:12:40 PM
 Name: jim

Comments:
I'm jealous

09/10/2003 5:57:39 PM
 Name: andriej

Comments:
If you don't like this monument I want it. Please send it to my garden :)

09/10/2003 7:06:49 PM
 Name: John

Comments:
The size of things look about right to me. If you are going to show a little national pride don't sell your culture short!

09/10/2003 7:17:39 PM
 Name: Todd Kinderfeld

Comments:
How come they didn't make him with an erection? That would have really been making a statement about freedom.

09/10/2003 8:25:45 PM
 Name: Denise

Comments:
The whole point of art is that it is free expression of the artist's mind. No one should expect it to conform to any other person's ideals.

09/10/2003 9:51:35 PM
 Name: WGB

Comments:
There is absolutely nothing wrong with this piece of art. Art teaches, and guides, this sculpture celebrates EMANCIPATION, not only from slavery but from restrictions placed on us by society. There is absolutley nothing wrong with the nude human form. Keep this sculpture and be proud and free. Thank You

09/10/2003 9:58:35 PM
 Name: Just Me

Comments:
I believe the sculpture is beautiful. There is nothing wrong with it. Everyone seems to be complaining about the man's penis and not about the famale's body. Here goes the typical debate of male v. famale. It's okay for a female to be nude but it's whole 380 when it's a male. Get it together and respect the artist and her art. Maybe you should get your mind out of the gutter and see it for what it really is.

09/10/2003 11:41:43 PM
 Name: Clark

Comments:
This is a great statue. To all the people who are obsessing over the man's member, I think that says something about the viewers themselves, not the art. For the love of Pete, it's just a penis!

09/11/2003 3:01:16 AM
 Name: roger

Comments:
People are just too insecure. Anatolomical accuracy freightens some people. Plus - we've all seen bigger.

09/11/2003 8:04:36 AM
 Name: Zane Page

Comments:
Don't be so prudish--Americans are like that, you aren't. Enjoy the statue and its celebration

09/11/2003 8:26:57 AM
 Name: from2ch

Comments:
Big CHINKO. UTAMARO!

09/11/2003 8:51:28 AM
 Name: Pedro

Comments:
What's the problem? It's mankind!

09/11/2003 8:58:03 AM
 Name: ( ´∀`)

Comments:
GOOD JOB!

09/11/2003 9:09:06 AM
 Name: Mongol800

Comments:
I think that there is no strange point in this statue.

09/11/2003 9:20:41 AM
 Name: (・∀・)イイ

Comments:
DEKAINA OI!

09/11/2003 9:30:08 AM
 Name: (・∀・)イイ

Comments:
DEKAINA OI!

09/11/2003 9:30:49 AM
 Name: 名無しさん@4周年

Comments:
i wanna be like this

09/11/2003 9:31:27 AM
 Name: edvard

Comments:
ochen horoshow

09/11/2003 10:27:39 AM
 Name: Dave

Comments:
I feel it is moving and honest portrayal. For those who insist that the man is over endowed, well there are those who say the same about the Statue of David. Both potray young men. Both are in proper proportion for young men. Slavers did not import older men, they looked for young healthy men in their late teens early twenties. David was about 14-16. In that context their bodies are in proper proportion.

09/11/2003 11:10:50 AM
 Name: Gnome

Comments:
No doubt that some people will never "see" art. They only see something filtered through their lenses. The naysayers must reprioritize... there are more pressing issues that are real obcenities abound.

09/11/2003 12:18:19 PM
 Name: Timmy Coregilus

Comments:
I'm threatend by a large cock. Take it down.

09/11/2003 2:27:58 PM
 Name: Sharon

Comments:
art has always caused controversy

09/11/2003 2:34:28 PM
 Name: Islanddiva06

Comments:
People need to stop being so uptight!

09/11/2003 2:47:34 PM
 Name: kealei

Comments:
What a beautiful work of are by a local artisan. Jamaicans should be proud of the talent and show them support instead of trying to tell them what is art and what is not art.

09/11/2003 2:55:01 PM
 Name: Gary

Comments:
The nakedness and the "size" are not offensive in the least. However, the statue doesn't go with the theme as well as it might. There are worse things one might find on the radio, or tv, or cinema.

09/11/2003 3:00:20 PM
 Name: Chung

Comments:
I love big weapon!

09/11/2003 3:57:49 PM
 Name: Chung

Comments:
I love big weapon!

09/11/2003 3:58:00 PM
 Name: Mike McKinley

Comments:

09/11/2003 4:11:15 PM
 Name: Craig Crapia

Comments:
with its height, it give many something to look up too!

09/11/2003 4:38:18 PM
 Name: Stewart Dickson

Comments:
May we all be so free! Namaste'

09/11/2003 7:26:12 PM
 Name: paff

Comments:

09/12/2003 5:40:56 AM
 Name: Mark Gross

Comments:
It exudes power, hope and...actually innocence. I'm having trouble seeing the "Europeaness" of the woman's features. It has my humble blessings

09/12/2003 8:50:19 PM
 Name: Anita Stewart

Comments:
I do believe that our people are stuck in an immature place of placing the focus on the "private" parts of the body. We are still hating our bodies and too ashamed of sex and sexuality.

09/13/2003 1:11:21 AM
 Name: T.M.

Comments:
It doesn't appeal to my sence of beauty...

09/13/2003 3:16:47 AM
 Name: T.M.

Comments:
It doesn't appeal to my sence of beauty...

09/13/2003 3:18:54 AM
 Name: Utamaro

Comments:
I want to approve of statue, but author had better remanufacture the penis of a bronze sculpture. What is necessary is just to make it "phimosis" like Michelangelo's David sculpture. A reason is that it can express purity simultaneously with brawniness. And "it" is not conspicuous. Thank you for understanding my english.

09/13/2003 10:02:44 AM
 Name: Nikki Ponto

Comments:
It's time we accepted the human form as natural. It's a BEAUTIFUL statue. I love it. reguards Hollow

09/14/2003 2:55:58 AM
 Name: Die

Comments:
bigger is better. be proud.

09/14/2003 11:02:36 AM
 Name: gary

Comments:
The statue is beautiful .But I am surprised that no one is crying about the female nudity and how women are exploited . That's what most of the politically correct critics cry about.

09/14/2003 11:59:35 AM
 Name:

Comments:

09/14/2003 11:20:44 PM
 Name:

Comments:
That thing is the right size. What is the deal?.....lol...They are both beautiful. Why are peeps so uptight about the black penis any way, are we brothas ashamed of of size?

09/15/2003 3:31:56 AM
 Name: Rose

Comments:
Why are there no disapprovals of the nudity of the woman? Secondly would it spark comment if the tool was small? AAAnyway.. the butt on that man is hmmmm.

09/15/2003 1:57:59 PM
 Name: Nadine N. Peru

Comments:
Tell all the nay sayer's to go way!!! I think that the statue is beautiful. It's positive. Can't people look beyond the fact that there are "body parts" showing! I mean, that's not where it ends! There's meaning behind the statue, look at it and wonder. Look at it and imagine. Grab on to the ART of it all. Ponder on the title of the statue, the meaning behind the title. Let's not limit ourselves to the obvious. Dig deeper people, dig deeper! Great Job!

09/15/2003 6:13:49 PM
 Name:

Comments:

09/15/2003 7:47:06 PM
 Name:

Comments:

09/16/2003 5:45:42 AM
 Name: Toops

Comments:
How can you fault the motive? In my understanding, the figures are symbolic of freedom- freed from the shackles and prejudices of society! The figures are an expression of thoughts, feelings and beliefs and are a work of art. Nice one mate!

09/16/2003 2:28:01 PM
 Name: Nadine Salter

Comments:
JESUS CHRIST!!!! THATS HUGE!!!! IF ONLY ALL MEN WERE THAT WELL ENDOWED

09/16/2003 2:52:43 PM
 Name: Moe

Comments:
Rubish, The only time that mankind was unashamed of his genitals was in the Garden of Eden before he disobediently ate the so called tree of knowledge. Since then even the cave people took care to cover their genitals with leaves. So what is the cry about the west making us feel ashamed of our "beautiful African Bodies." Where are our values?

09/18/2003 1:16:30 AM
 Name: tamika

Comments:
I think the sculpture is a sign of hope for the future of the jamaican people and should be left as it is

09/19/2003 6:39:33 AM
 Name:

Comments:

09/20/2003 2:04:58 AM
 Name: koiking

Comments:
hahaha! IT's a very fun!

09/20/2003 6:04:24 AM
 Name: Matt

Comments:
Michelangelo's David is naked and he's not exactly small or modest and we revere that sculpture as a monumental work. So what's the big deal about this one?

09/21/2003 3:28:46 AM
 Name:

Comments:
redemption song by steve porter ゥ i am so glad that laura facey cooper made a statue with a big penis because presence isss better than absence a beautiful banana-bronzed rendering of a handsomely-endowed jamaican standing next to his equally naked woman apparently its gotten some people upset like when larry rivers used frank ohara and his big cock as a new american prototype its so obvious they havent forgiven you laura for making such a stud out of jesus and now they just want to crucify you once again but we understand words like freedom pride liberation and naked humility and know they dont die on no damn cross.

09/21/2003 4:03:14 PM
 Name: Saeed A Qawee

Comments:
I do understand that my desendants were robbed of everything.However,this level of nudity is unacceptable.this is a blatant promotion of Heathenism.Would you walk around like that? Furthermore,its a big Sin to mek dem ting dey(images)

09/22/2003 12:53:15 AM
 Name: J. A. Campbell

Comments:
Is this only way we can think of to honour our slave ancestors? Displaying them in the nude is real disrespect to them. Did our ancestors stand in the nude in public for the slave masters and fellow slaves to view them? I don't think so. Would all of you who agree with the way these work of ""ART"" is displayed, make the same "work of Art" of your Mother and Father and displayed them in your front yard for the public to see your mother and father private parts? Even our Coat of Arms from the Arawack days cover their private parts. Do we stand around showing our privates parts to all who want to see? If we realy understood what our slaves ancestors went trought in slave days, we would find a better way to respect and honour them. The Statues are fine, but cover the nudity please Mr PRIME MINISTER

09/22/2003 10:01:47 PM
 Name:

Comments:
bull bout redemption song, people these days just always think negative.

09/25/2003 12:01:05 AM
 Name: B. Lewis

Comments:
Looks good to me.

09/27/2003 5:47:08 AM
 Name:

Comments:

09/29/2003 5:34:03 PM
 Name: ke-ke pop

Comments:
Love the monument!!!!!!! great work!!!!!! what u people want to see? whips and chains? seems to me like you need to free yourselves from small mind!!!!!!!!!!!

10/01/2003 2:11:12 PM
 Name: Natalie

Comments:
It is a very beautiful statue. People must stop looking at the penise and look at the real meaning of the statue

10/02/2003 12:51:22 PM
 Name: mark

Comments:
we as Jamaicans are too hang up on nudity

10/05/2003 9:54:19 AM
 Name:

Comments:
I'm amazed that this has happened. I have a friend who recently did a Marcus Garvey sculpture, but the organization that commissioned it are not able to pay for it. Anybody interested? email me at belriver@aol.com

10/08/2003 2:42:30 PM
 Name:

Comments:
nuthin wrong with nudity but it don't look natural the way the sculpter did it. some ting wrong with the way it hang.

10/15/2003 8:16:15 AM
 Name: a lively

Comments:

10/16/2003 5:54:07 AM
 Name:

Comments:
The penis shows the truth about Jamaican men. No need to lie or try to hide it.

10/16/2003 6:00:46 AM
 Name: amidat

Comments:
Do think it is about time the topic changes.

10/16/2003 1:26:42 PM
 Name: amidat

Comments:
sorry wrong flag

10/16/2003 1:28:54 PM
 Name: d

Comments:
Stupid

10/18/2003 3:46:26 PM
 Name: D.A.W.G.

Comments:
I really don't know what's wrong with being naked, I mean, what if the person who invented clothes never invented clothes, we all would be walking around naked now. It's just like we see everyone's 'nose' everyday, we would see everyone naked eeveryday and it would have been a natural thing.

10/18/2003 4:00:44 PM
 Name: Samantha

Comments:
It's beautiful and powerful and Africans need to start loving themselves and how we look - we've been told we are not beautiful for far too long! As far as EMANCIPATION - I see the surrounding water as symbolic of the cleansing of mental and physical slavery...

10/29/2003 9:22:58 PM
 Name: Samantha

Comments:
It's beautiful and powerful and Africans need to start loving themselves and how we look - we've been told we are not beautiful for far too long! As far as EMANCIPATION - I see the surrounding water as symbolic of the cleansing of mental and physical slavery...

10/29/2003 9:25:49 PM
 Name:

Comments:

11/04/2003 3:23:12 AM
 Name: DEL DEL

Comments:

11/26/2003 6:01:20 PM
 Name: DEL DEL

Comments:
I LIKE YOU JAMAICA

11/26/2003 6:04:37 PM
 Name: DEL DEL

Comments:
I LIKE YOU JAMICAN

11/26/2003 6:08:10 PM
 Name: ben

Comments:
i think its good that people like get things out in the open i respect the artest completly wel dun

11/30/2003 2:56:11 PM
 Name:

Comments:
i think the statue symbolizes the upliftment of our people and it is a sign of upward mobility.

12/09/2003 2:53:17 PM
 Name: Tanisha Lawrence

Comments:
I think the statue represents exactly what the artist intended it to. The only issue is that statue does not adequately represent the Black man's endowment - its 'manhood' should have been bigger!

12/09/2003 8:20:28 PM
 Name: marsha

Comments:
I think that if most jamaicans knew our history and knew how to interpret works of art then would understand what this sculpture is saying.

12/10/2003 9:23:02 AM
 Name: Diogo

Comments:
What is the BIG deal?

12/22/2003 2:03:03 PM
 Name: marie grossett

Comments:

12/23/2003 11:17:12 AM
 Name: precious

Comments:
This is a wonderful work of art, there is absolutely nothing wrong with our nakedness and we need to come to grips with it.

01/09/2004 3:45:02 AM
 Name:

Comments:
I don't think that big cock is suitable for children to see.. it might reflect shame upon them when they are older.. they could have picked something better.

02/13/2004 6:36:58 AM
 Name: terence

Comments:
the beauty of art has nothing to do with nudity. free your mind.

02/19/2004 12:24:04 PM
 Name: Nicola

Comments:
I really like the statue. It speaks to freedom, that what all Jamaicans should aspire to have.

03/02/2004 11:53:57 AM
 Name: audrey matura

Comments:
very artistic! love the zrt in it and the message as well

03/10/2004 5:34:03 PM
 Name: Dylon Bess

Comments:
Nudity is everywhere,at some point and time everyone including children will be, if not already exposed to it. If its the nudity the public is worried about since it is a national Statute you know where to find it and can avoid it. Its merely an expression of one's interpretation of a particular pheonomenonemancipation

03/12/2004 5:53:49 PM
 Name: Lyn

Comments:
Artistically great, Love the theme, Not offended by nudeness, but I don't think it depicts freedom/emancipation.

03/13/2004 4:43:07 PM
 Name:

Comments:
Iam very intersted to sing a song.

04/08/2004 10:50:10 AM
 Name: Rui Baptista-Goncalves

Comments:
I think this is a beatiful work of art, regardless of its meaning of emancipation. I have to agree that it doesnt perfectly describes emancipation, but if I was jamaican I would feel proud of it.

05/21/2004 7:12:22 AM
 Name: jim

Comments:

06/08/2004 7:44:57 AM
 Name: natscott

Comments:
I am actually doing a paper on the socio-cultural and aesthetic issues that have evolved from this monument, hence the resposes here will be very helpful. Thanks

06/13/2004 8:50:36 PM
 Name: roy

Comments:
man this is a true work of art and expression,the artist deserve a medal for this.we as jamaican should be proud of it.some brothers who dissoprove of this fine piece of art,because of the man cock,well you know they are packing a piece of teely,well if they cannot look beyond the cock,then something is wrong,me i am long,black and stout plus proud.fine piece of art.

08/26/2004 3:04:31 PM
 Name: Pete Menard

Comments:
I think it's beautiful and tasteful. The human body is nothing to be ashamed of!!!

09/07/2004 7:19:57 PM
 Name: MS REEN

Comments:
" Why R we so... critical, & negative so, much negativety & nothin' positive" WHY?

09/09/2004 9:59:25 PM
 Name: Clyde Bridger

Comments:
Why do people get all upset about the nude human form? Everyone has a body, be it male or female. So, what's the big deal? Get over it! According to the bible,God created man in his own image. Therefore, if we are to be ashamed of our bodies, then we are also shameful and disrespectful to our God aswell!

10/03/2004 8:39:55 PM
 Name:

Comments:
The Truth is the Truth !

10/05/2004 2:33:18 PM
 Name: lovie

Comments:
no way, this is awful just lower this statue in the water to the waist,this is a beautiful statue dont waste it just cover it

10/11/2004 1:20:55 AM
 Name: JAMAICAN BEAUTY KADIAN M.C.

Comments:
Jamaican's STAND UP and be PROUD!!!! the statue is a GREAT symbol of our country don't be ashame of it. i remember dad my when my dad asked me what i thought of the statue i was ashamed to answer but now i'm more mature and i know the statue goes with the theme "none but our selve can free our mind" white man have told us we ugly but come on now!!!

10/26/2004 10:52:34 PM
 Name: Alex Routh

Comments:
I love it! I'd like to know where I can find some living embodiments of the man, I'd like to suck him dry!

11/07/2004 4:55:44 AM
 Name: roman

Comments:
halloo, i have the statue Ganesha 100cm stone java from singosari dinasty weight 400kg if you interest pls contac me in this email

11/07/2004 11:22:57 PM
 Name: Rohan

Comments:
Freedom of expression, appreciation for the arts!

12/01/2004 10:36:10 AM
 Name: Bridget

Comments:
It is sad when people can only see the human form as a sexual object rather than a thing of beauty. It it a beautiful statue that truly reflects the word "emancipation"

12/01/2004 11:03:52 AM
 Name: missi

Comments:
It is a good sculpture, and so what if the stutes are naked we are liveing in the 20th centry and it's about time we got over nudity and look at the symbol of the stutes.it seem's we are a stong race and should be happy about it.

12/06/2004 2:15:06 PM
 Name: Germain

Comments:
Thats One Thing I Know No One Is Goin To Move! Both statues Signifies Not Only Freedom But the True Jamaican Art And Also By Looking At It Reviles Our Nationality. It Make No Sense To Start A Controversy On Why The Sculptor Was Created Without Clothes And Why The Guy Had To have A Large Penis Those Were Put There For A Reason And To Show As A Symbol For People To Recognized.....A Man With A Big Buddy And A Naked Lady Ya'll Get IT?

12/13/2004 10:16:06 AM
 Name: Luke Basketfield

Comments:
Bob Marley spoke of the prophecies his words emblazoned on this statue truly captivates peoples mind. to take it down would be a crime! the mans large penis is not the issue, its the message behind the music. redemption song one love jammin who can forget such classics? JAH LIVES!

12/15/2004 4:17:31 AM
 Name:

Comments:

12/20/2004 1:12:42 AM
 Name: Alex and Jelisa

Comments:
That is something else...I think it looks hott!

12/25/2004 1:00:00 AM
 Name: Jasmine

Comments:
That shyt is tight, i think its an intelligent peice of art work and we should get one in Tobago, Trinidad...

12/25/2004 1:01:36 AM
 Name: mimi fart

Comments:

01/05/2005 4:55:54 PM
 Name: lorrie-ann

Comments:
that's the way we were born, why be ashame!

01/19/2005 10:15:23 AM
 Name: jcool

Comments:
this statu is great but what about the non artisik people and the childern the monument should not be in puplic,they should have put it in a musium.

01/25/2005 8:27:35 PM
 Name: susan

Comments:
every one has a deffient opion

02/02/2005 5:51:01 PM
 Name: kimberley

Comments:
I THINK THE STATUE IS MONEY BUT IT TURNED OUT GOOD IN THE END IN THE TOURISM SECTION.

02/03/2005 4:59:41 PM
 Name: TAHIBITA SHUZZSEDA

Comments:

02/03/2005 5:08:18 PM
 Name: TAHIBITA SHUZZSEADESA

Comments:
Young kids should not be seeing these things in visual appearances.

02/03/2005 5:19:41 PM
 Name: mickesha

Comments:

02/04/2005 4:10:17 PM
 Name: mickesha

Comments:

02/04/2005 4:10:41 PM
 Name: mickesha

Comments:
I think the statue shows the true value of jamaican people in their independence.It shows how much freedom we have gotten over the years and even now. We don't have anyone watching over us. Good job girl and nuff respect.

02/04/2005 4:14:56 PM
 Name: Hansa

Comments:
It sucks

02/05/2005 3:45:19 PM
 Name: Hansa

Comments:
Nudity is not necessary to the society. They could have at least covered his penis! I think it should be taken down because people might think they're having sex! Nothing bout emancipation! I just wanna send shoutouts to sasha, j-cool, mickesha and susan!

02/05/2005 4:45:48 PM
 Name: Hana

Comments:
Hi mickesha ,j-cool and sasha!

02/05/2005 6:50:23 PM
 Name: GL

Comments:
KEEP THE FLAME BURNING!

02/10/2005 6:12:50 AM
 Name: Talufa

Comments:
i so disapprove of dis statue mon! id so rada see doez fakaz humpin!

03/18/2005 11:27:55 AM
 Name: Asif

Comments:
They seem to be basking in the light of their freedom. "in a free state". Someone chained by religion would be offended...those of us in the true process of freedom will grow and appreciate.

03/21/2005 2:56:42 PM
 Name:

Comments:

03/31/2005 5:26:10 PM
 Name: Laima

Comments:
I think it is beautiful in classical sense.

04/11/2005 10:17:15 AM
 Name: Rarah

Comments:
I think it's beautiful, but then again I understand the controversey,but all together I think it,s nice.

04/16/2005 4:48:57 PM
 Name: Kraze

Comments:
I Love it, and support it!

04/16/2005 4:50:11 PM


Afiwi ISP | Sign Up | About Us | top of page | previous page
copyright 2001 all rights reserved iCarib-Media Inc